
Whenever people ask me “What should I say?” (and they do, which is odd, because I am world champion at saying exactly the wrong thing at precisely the wrong time) I always give the same answer, “Just tell the truth.” It is so much easier than trying to manage a landscape of falsehoods, however well-intentioned they may be. A little white lie in order to shield someone from a painful truth is all well and good, but they are none-the-less unlikely to be happy when they find out you have been lying to them. Lies will always find you out.
I’m not suggesting that you go out of your way to be brutal with the truth – friends don’t do that – but I do know that the protection offered by a lie is transient and that the truth becomes even more painful when the ‘shield’ has faded. Saying “Yes” when your best friend asks you, “Does my arse look big in this?” is unlikely to score you brownie points, but hiding the truth could be worse. “It looks like a balloon!” probably doesn’t strike quite the right note – even if true – and “Well, I’ve seen bigger,” is not necessarily any better, but if you care and you try, you will find a way. (If you are a male, you may be faced with the even knottier problem of ‘Here, do you think this is normal?’ in which instance neither ‘yes’ or ‘no’ is the correct response.) You are mistaken if you expect me to offer any guide to what you should be saying – I have the antithesis of a silver tongue, probably pig-iron – I spend too long with my foot in my mouth to make my words easily decipherable. When all else fails, suggest calling The Citizen’s Advice Bureau.
My welded bond to ‘the truth’ is seldom bound to piety but is wound up instead to the simple practicalities of my own ineptitude. I am no paragon of virtue; simply aware of my culpability as a major-league beacon of incompetence. I spend most of my life feeling as though I really ought to be apologising, but seldom sure of what about and to whom. I am the king of obfuscation: not by intention, but by inability to consider either lying or knowingly causing distress. If you have a secret I think I might be a bad friend. I certainly wouldn’t ‘tell’ on purpose (actually, that is not strictly true, in certain circumstances, dependent upon the nature of the ‘secret’, I suspect that I almost certainly would) but I would also find it difficult to actually lie: secrets kind of ooze out of me, not voluntarily, but by action or reaction. They find their way out by some kind of osmosis. Friends and family know instinctively that I have a secret to keep and, should they suspect that they may be on the receiving end of let’s say a surprise birthday party, they keep their distance from me in the certain knowledge that it won’t be long before I accidentally reveal that I can’t look after the kids because I’m waiting in for a delivery of champagne for your… bugger, bugger, bugger! I have been the unwitting nub of familial data breaches, on the basis of pure incompetence, more often than I would care to remember. “Don’t tell mum, but…” is the signal for me to go to pieces. It is far better that I am given neither bag nor cat to let out of it. Happily, most people who know me understand that I am a lost cause and choose not to burden me, because when I let go of a ‘good’ secret, I won’t lie, I feel wretched.
