Why? Again

In which I attempt to answer some of the questions asked by my grandchildren…

  1. Are Unicorns real? – “Yes, of course Unicorns are real.  You would cry if I said ‘No’ wouldn’t you?”  “Yes.”  “Fine.  Unicorns are real.”
  2. Are there monsters under the bed? – “That depends on whether you intend to tell nana about the big bowl of trifle you saw me with earlier today…”
  3. How do escalators work?  – “A perfectly logical question to which, amazingly, I know the answer.  Escalators are really just like a single band spinning around fixed points at the base and at the top.”  “So the steps are underneath as well?”  “Yes, they are.”  “Why don’t the people fall off them?”  “There are no people underneath them, everyone is on top.”  “Even in Australia?”  “Even in Australia.”  “Maybe the people in Australia fall off the top…”  I find this difficult to contest as I, myself, am not certain why the entire population Down Under is not prone to dizzy spells due to all the blood rushing to their heads.  Also, if the water spins in the opposite direction before going down a plughole, does that mean that the bottom half of the world is spinning the other way?  If that is so, how do ships ever cross the equator?
  4. Are there rainbows in space? – “I don’t think so.  There has to be rain for there to be a rainbow and there’s no rain in space…”  “But Unicorns need rainbows to run along.”  “I see.  And you would be very sad if the Unicorns (the existence of which I have just confirmed) did not have rainbows to run along?  Yes, well, of course, I overlooked the fact that science knows nothing.  Of course there are rainbows in space…  Yes, and princesses in glittery cloaks…”
  5. Why is the sky blue? – “Because Mrs God wanted it to be a nice sunny yellow, but God found a job lot of (what later became) Sky Blue going cheap at the paint merchants and a man who was prepared to slap on a single coat for next to nothing.”
  6. Why have we stopped? – “Because all the cars ahead of us have stopped.”  “Why?”  “Because the traffic lights are red.”  “Why?”  “Because we have to let some other cars out.”  “Why?”  “Because it is their turn.”  “Why?”  “Because their traffic light is green.”  “Why?”  “Because that’s how traffic lights work.”  “Why?”  “To stop us all from crashing into one another.”  “Why?”  “Honestly, I don’t know.  I wish really that I hadn’t bothered and just crashed into the car in front, impaling myself on the steering column and…  Oh look, the lights are green, we can go now.”  “Why?”
  7. Why do you grunt when you get out of the car? – “Because I am old and my muscles ache sometimes.”  “Pigs grunt.”  “Maybe their muscles ache too.”
  8. Why are you so old? – “Because I was born a long, long time ago.”  “Before mummy was born?”  “Yes, before mummy was born.  I am her daddy.”  “Are you daddy’s daddy too?”  “No darling, we don’t live in Caistor*.”  “What’s Caistor?”  “It’s a place where people live.”  “Like France?”  “Almost exactly like France, yes.”
  9. When are you going to die? – “Not too soon I hope.”  “Old people die don’t they?”  “Well, yes, but I’m not going to die for a while.  Don’t worry.”  “Who will take me to school when you die?”  “I hope you will be finished school before I die.  I hope that you will be all grown up.  Maybe you will have children yourself.”  “Can I have a biscuit?”  “Yes, you can have a biscuit.” 
  10. Why? – “Because…”

*A local village, famous for it.

N.B. It wasn’t until I had finished this post that I realised I had used the title ‘Why?’ before, prompted, I think, by somebody who is no longer four-years old. That is why I have changed the title of this piece to ‘Why? Again’. If you wish to read the fiirst ‘Why?’, you can find it here…

I also find that I have previously used the image at the top of this piece in a previous post ‘Answers? Questions! Questions? Answers!’

Answers? Questions! Questions? Answers!*

Photo by Emily Morter on Unsplash

In my last blog (Working Title) I attempted to answer the questions posed by Petra in her Writing Questions for YOU post.  Not unusually for me, a few dozen words became a few hundred and I ended my own post having answered (in a peculiarly roundabout way, I admit) only one of her questions.  I promised (threatened) to answer the others and, unfortunately, this is the best I have yet managed.  The questions seemed to me, serious ones, so I have given them some consideration and answered them as honestly as I can.  This is not my strength, so please forgive me if I meander… 

The first question asked whether dreams have ever provided inspiration for stories and, if so, how?  I have two main problems with dreams as inspiration:

  1. In general, I do not remember them, and
  2. I am never totally convinced that everything is not a dream: that my entire life is not merely a figment of somebody else’s fevered nocturnal machinations, in which case it is just possible that my dreams are reality and the reason I don’t remember them is because they are incredibly tedious.

I don’t believe that I have ever knowingly written anything based on a dream, but I have written about dreams in a post, way back in November 2019 (All You Ever Wanted to Know About Dreams, But Were Afraid to Ask), so if you truly seek the answers, they just might be there.

The next can of worms (I’m sorry, ‘question’) involved writing about other races and genders. Well, I truly have never questioned the ethnicity of any of my characters. (Does that make me racist?) They just are. I cannot claim to be content with that, but in my small world, everybody is the same under the skin, and skin is just that – something to keep the rain off. I am perfectly happy to talk about racism; it is inherently, futilely evil and pernicious, but writing about it within the kind of posts that I write would simply trivialise it, and I have no desire to do that. There are many who are perfectly capable of articulating the sheer iniquity of it, but I am not one of them. Most of my characters, at heart, are me and they are whatever colour, whatever diaspora you choose for them. I very much hope that you like them when they are likeable and dislike them when they are not.

As for gender, well, I have to admit that the gender of my characters often changes during writing.  If you have ever read any of the Dinah and Shaw Little Fictions, you should know that Dinah is almost certainly me, but then again, so is Shaw…  I think in most respects we are similar – we laugh at the same things, get mad at the same things, cry at the same things regardless of reproductive arrangements.  In a few respects however, we are completely different and that has to be celebrated.  If you can consider those differences in a way that both sexes find amusing, well, that’s comedy gold isn’t it?  If you ever find a way of doing it, please let me know.  (The late, great Victoria Wood handled it effortlessly.  Unfortunately few of us, if any, will ever possess such talent.)

I am a passionate believer that, fundamentally, we are all the same and that we should, therefore, all be afforded exactly the same opportunities in life – which we patently are not.  I have no idea how we can put that right.  Antagonising a certain type of person will just entrench their views; preaching only ever appeals to the already converted.  If I can make somebody think by making them smile well, at least it’s a start isn’t it?  I’m not keen on confrontation and I would never seek to deliberately offend (although I have no doubt that I may have inadvertently done so a thousand times) and I think that seriously limits me, but it does mean that I have never published anything that I truly regret.  I regret having published things that I now realise were just not good enough, but that’s a whole different bucket of frogs. I’m annoyed that I can’t do better, but ashamed?  I don’t think so.  There’s always time though…

One thing I seldom, if ever, stick my nose into is religion.  As far as I can see, there is more than enough room in this world for anyone to believe whatever they choose to believe.  I completely understand why religion is so emotive, I understand the passion.  What I don’t understand is why the passion so readily becomes violence.  I cannot believe that hatred of ‘others’ is a true tenet of any religion.  You may say that I’m a dreamer etc etc.

Finally (at last!) the question of style. Do I Work on Style? Well, patently not. Take a read through my ‘back catalogue’ and you will be absolutely assured of my lack of it. I fear that ‘This Man Had No Style’ may well be my epitaph. As for genre, well, other than the constant attempt to grapple a little humour from everything I write, I don’t really think I work within one. I hope that, other than being filed under ‘drivel’, I am not that easy to categorise.

So, that’s it.  I have tried to answer the questions honestly.  I hope you will forgive me if I promise not to do it again.

When you know the answers, I think, perhaps, you keep them to yourself…

*Focus (1972)